Author - ab_mnbr

In Libya we could move towards a state of emergency

Mauro Indelicato
In front of the Tobruck parliament building , the rubble is still smoking. On Friday , the assault by demonstrators against the building that since 2014 has housed what is considered the “Lower House” of Libyan institutions left a considerable mark. Read More

Libya, the Failure of the Elite

Tarek Megerisi

Libyans have always had a proud sense of exceptionalism. Despite attempts to compare Libya to Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, and even uprisings from France to Russia, their own revolution has long retained this sense of exceptionalism, too. Today, however, over eleven years later, the dust has settled upon a much more mundanely tyrannical new world. Read More

Libya Could Make or Break Biden’s Middle East Oil Diplomacy

Increased Saudi production will mean little if Libyan oil production remains unreliable.

Ben Fishman

President Joe Biden is clearly not enthused about traveling to Saudi Arabia. He insists that his views on human rights have not changed and said he would not meet Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman privately. Read More

Elements of success and failure of the protests

Abdullah Alkabir

Those who cannot read the reality that stemmed from the recent past, which sap is still ascending from the roots of this past to the stems and leaves of the present, will be taken by surprise by the outbreak of violent demonstrations in the four corners of the country at the beginning of July. This is so, despite the preparations and calls through the social media few days ago. Read More

Is the Iraq’s notorious ‘Oil for Food Program’ to be repeated in Libya?

Mustafa Fetouri

The United States Ambassador to Tripoli, Richard Norland, who is also his country’s Envoy to Libya, has been openly pushing forward a plan to deny the Libyan State the freedom of using the oil revenues in accordance with Libyan sovereignty over its resource. Oil makes roughly 98 per cent of the country’s foreign currency earnings and the country has plenty of it. Read More

Book Review – “Revolutionary Life: The Everyday of the Arab Spring” by Asef Bayat

Massaoud Romdhani

From the perspective of an ordinary observer, the 2011 Arab Spring, which was sparked in Tunisia and spread like wildfire to Egypt and other Arab countries, has been a bitter failure. Even Tunisia’s fragile democracy, once the only apparent bright spot in the entire landscape, has now reached a similar failed fate after President Kais Saied seized full power, shuttering down the parliament, freezing institutions, and ruling by decree. Read More

Libya’s Power Cuts Angry Citizens and Protests Rise

 Carolina Gomes

António Guterres, the UN secretary-general, has asked for peace and calm, especially during the public protests that are generally increasing across Libya over power cuts and failure to hold elections. The poor economic conditions and the rise of oil and bread prices are also valid complaints. Read More

Tarhuna could have 100 mass graves

A UN report details how Kaniyat militia fighters executed and imprisoned hundreds of people between 2016-2020.

A United Nations-appointed mission to Libya has said there are “probable mass graves” yet to be investigated, possibly as many as 100, in a town where hundreds of bodies have already been found.

The report to be submitted to the UN Human Rights Council this week details how fighters from the Kaniyat militia executed and imprisoned hundreds of people between 2016 and 2020, sometimes keeping them in tiny oven-like structures called “the boxes”, which were set alight during interrogations.

The evidence of kidnappings, murder and torture in Tarhuna, uncovered by the independent fact-finding mission, represents one of the most egregious examples of rights abuses in the turbulent period since Muammar Gaddafi’s removal in 2011.

Among the victims were disabled people, as well as women and children, the 51-page report said.

Based on the testimonies of residents and two site visits, the mission found “reasonable grounds” that the Kaniyat militia committed crimes against humanity. It identified four commanders who participated directly in them.

Libyan authorities have already recovered 247 bodies in mass and individual grave sites in the Tarhuna area in western Libya. Many of the victims were still handcuffed and blindfolded.

The mission used satellite imagery showing signs of soil disturbances among other evidence to identify three new likely sites. But there could be many more, it said, citing an existing grave known as “The Landfill” where just a tiny fraction of the site has been investigated.

According to insider knowledge, there might still be up to 100 as of yet undiscovered mass graves,” the report said.

It is not immediately clear how the findings will reflect on Libyan authorities. Libya’s diplomatic mission in Geneva has not made a statement about the issue.

Allied with both governments

At one stage, the Kaniyat was aligned with the Tripoli-based Government of National Accord but later with the eastern Libyan National Army, led by General Khalifa Haftar that tried, unsuccessfully, to overthrow the internationally recognised National Accord administration. The fighters no longer hold authority in Tarhuna.

The surviving leaders of the Kaniyat are mostly believed to have fled to areas of eastern Libya under Haftar’s control.

In its conclusions, the fact-finding mission (FFM) calls on Libyan authorities to continue searching for the graves. It also urges them to establish a special tribunal to prosecute international crimes.

Tracy Robinson, one of the three heads in charge of the 18-person team, said it did not have the resources or authority to investigate the Tarhuna graves alone. “It’s the state’s duty to act,” she told journalists in Geneva.

The report refers to difficulties with the cooperation of Libyan authorities in the past. Diplomats and UN sources told Reuters that Libya had previously expressed reservations about continuing the mission, which expires this month.

A resolution is currently before the Geneva-based council to keep investigations going for another nine months, which is less than some had hoped for.

A decision is expected this week and, if successful, FFM members said they intend to submit further evidence, a final report and a confidential list of individual suspects to the council next year.

************

UN rights mission finds ‘probable’ mass graves in Libya

A UN-appointed mission to Libya said on Monday there are “probable mass graves” yet to be investigated, possibly as many as 100, in a town where hundreds of bodies have already been found, and it urged Tripoli to keep searching, Reuters reports.

The report, to be submitted to the UN Human Rights Council this week, details how a militia run by seven brothers executed and imprisoned hundreds of people between 2016-2020, sometimes keeping them in tiny oven-like structures called “the boxes”, which were set alight during interrogations.

The evidence of kidnappings, murder and torture in Tarhouna, uncovered by the independent Fact-Finding Mission, represents one of the most egregious examples of rights abuses in the turbulent period since Muammar Gaddafi’s ousting in 2011.

Among the victims were the disabled, as well as women and children, the 51-page report said.

Based on the testimonies of residents and two site visits, the mission found “reasonable grounds” that the Kaniyat militia committed crimes against humanity. It identified four commanders who participated directly in them.

Already, Libyan authorities have recovered 247 bodies in mass and individual grave sites in the Tarhouna area in Western Libya. Many were still handcuffed and blindfolded.

The mission used satellite imagery showing signs of soil disturbances among other evidence to identify three new likely sites. But there could be many more, it said, citing an existing grave known as ‘The Landfill’, where just a tiny fraction of the site has been investigated.

“According to insider knowledge, there might still be up to 100 as of yet undiscovered mass graves,” the report said.

It is not immediately clear how the findings will reflect on Libyan authorities. Libya’s diplomatic mission in Geneva did not respond to a request for comment.

At one stage, the Kaniyat was aligned with the Tripoli-based Government of National Accord, but later with the eastern Libyan National Army led by Commander Khalifa Haftar, who tried, unsuccessfully, to overthrow the National Accord administration. The militia no longer holds authority in Tarhouna.

The surviving leaders of the Kaniyat are mostly believed to have fled to areas of eastern Libya under Haftar’s control.

In its conclusions, the Fact-Finding Mission (FFM) calls on Libyan authorities to continue searching for the graves. It also urges them to establish a special tribunal to prosecute international crimes.

Tracy Robinson, one of the three heads in charge of the 18-person team, said it did not have the resources or authority to investigate the Tarhouna graves alone. “It’s the State’s duty to act,” she told journalists in Geneva.

The report refers to difficulties with cooperation with Libyan authorities in the past. Diplomats and UN sources also told Reuters that Libya had previously expressed reservations about continuing the mission, which expires this month.

A resolution is currently before the Geneva-based council to keep investigations going for another nine months, which is less than what some had hoped for.

A decision is expected this week and, if successful, FFM members said they intend to submit further evidence, a final report and a confidential list of individual suspects to the Council next year.

_________________

Libya’s electoral limbo: The crisis of legitimacy

Amal Bourhrous

Eleven years after the downfall of Muammar Gaddafi, the situation in Libya remains extremely volatile. Elections planned for 24 December last year did not take place and the electoral process collapsed. As a result, Libya entered yet another period of deep political crisis, at the heart of which is (once again) a struggle over how to create a legitimate, national government. Read More

Non-security Challenges to Libya’s Economy

Hafed Al Ghwell

It cannot be understated that Libya stands at a critical juncture just over a decade after toppling Muammar Gaddafi’s 42-year-old regime. Predicting where the North African country will go, and how, remains a daunting exercise given the political turmoil caused by a still growing divide between competing visions for its future. Read More

Gulf Influence in Libya

Karim Mezran & Sabina Henneberg

Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, and Libya have experienced political turmoil since the Arab Spring uprisings of 2011. Read More

Features of the next stage

Abdullah Alkabir

Regardless of the premature interpretations by some of the parties of the European-American statement, according to their whims and desires, the language of the statement on the issue of the expiration of the Tunis-Geneva Agreement was very clear, and was specified in three clauses on the political level, and one on the economic aspect. Read More

In Gaddafi’s hometown, little hope for Libya’s future

Angus Mcdowall & Ahmed Elumami

Summary

The people living in the ruins of Sirte’s 600 Block district have waited years for help removing rubble and rebuilding homes damaged by warfare, but despite a new Libyan government making the city its headquarters, they have little hope of change. Read More

A Cancer At The Heart Of Libya’s Re-Emergence

Hafed Al-Ghwell

After roughly four months of high-level discussions between Libya’s two parliamentary chambers, the House of Representatives and the High Council of State, to determine a constitutional framework for a second attempt at national elections, the Libya file is yet again marked with another failure. Read More

Why do Libyans keep failing to settle their differences?

Mustafa Fetouri

In a statement issued in the earlier hours of 20 June, Stephanie Williams, the United Nations Special Advisor on Libya, drew the curtain on the Cairo talks between Libyan rivals as they failed to reach an agreement on the constitutional framework for any future elections. Read More